> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://shannonconnolly.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# On totes, and flourishing
- URL: https://shannonconnolly.org/on-totes-and-flourishing/
- Published: 2026-11-01T19:02:37.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-01T19:06:16.000Z
- Description: What public media in America could be
- Author: Shannon Connolly

When America built public media in 1967, it built a supplement, a side dish. Britain and the Nordic countries had built a commons decades earlier, the main course commercial media had to compete against. We built an alternative, the antidote to what an FCC chairman called television's "vast wasteland." Congress rejected the dedicated funding the Carnegie Commission recommended (twice) and chose annual appropriations, so for nearly sixty years public media depended on whoever controlled the budget. In 2025, the budget went away.

That's the bad news, and every station head I know is living it.

The good news is the design itself. Afraid of a state broadcaster, Congress built a thousand local ones instead: independent licenses, local towers, local voices. It meant America never had its BBC moment, a whole nation watching the Queen crowned on the same broadcast (unless you count OJ, or MJ, or NFL Sundays). But it left us a gift: independent stations in nearly every community, each equipped to create its own local sense of shared time and meaning.

We are in the middle of the biggest technological shift of my lifetime. It has us asking whether we'll continue to exist and, assuming we do, what human flourishing looks like. Who gets to decide how we live, work, and relate to each other in the AI or AGI age? We once trusted tech companies and Silicon Valley with these questions. Now we're looking elsewhere for answers.

Is there a media organization that can build trust (because it's human), a sense of truth (because it's independent, on the ground), shared time (because it's synchronous and accessible to all), and a sense of "we," not just "me"? Perhaps it's partly the storm warning everyone hears at once. Or Brian Lehrer taking calls on WNYC mid-morning, inviting neighbors who disagree onto the same show. A few thousand people listening to the same thing at the same moment, on purpose.

I believe public media’s original promise is part of what human flourishing requires. People always have, and always will, want what I call the 4Cs of public media…

… **creation**: facts we can trust about the place where we live and work, from someone who is there, with no agenda beyond telling us.

… **curation**: art, culture, and stories that are worthy of our attention, which is finite.

… **companionship**: trusted guides who take us places we'd never know to go ourselves, and remind us we are not listening alone.

… **community**: shared experiences, in physical and digital spaces, where we make sense of the world together.

So how might a station deliver on this? I see two seemingly paradoxical playbooks, that have to run in parallel.

**Embrace Constraints.** With fewer resources than ever, the most important strategic question is what you should stop doing. Less, not more. Not an innovation campaign. Not a better website. Not a podcast built for a national audience. Definitely not more social followers. Niche is the new reach: be known, and be essential to your community.

That starts with understanding both the audience you have and who you can sustainably win. That used to take an analytics team stitching together disparate broadcast, digital, and membership data. It doesn't anymore. And it's the foundation of good strategy, which works like a [razor](https://hbr.org/1996/11/what-is-strategy?ref=shannonconnolly.org). Why ask reporters to be "multi-platform," hustling to publish to five platforms a day, if the impact is in audio, or in visuals, rather than text? Why, on such limited resources, should we have any tolerance for trees falling in a forest?

Also, let's have no patience for friction-filled donations. Giving should be seamless, even delightful, as easy as Venmo'ing a friend when the check comes, or donating mid-stream the moment a host, a story, or a piece of music moves you. The systems that made this hard (the call center, the mobile-"optimized" donate page with endless fields, the kludgy, impenetrable CRM) used to be expensive to build and maintain. Not anymore. There are no excuses left. 

**Imagine Abundance.** First came Carnegie and Rockefeller, then Gates and Buffett. Next come the AI fortunes, possibly tens of billions of dollars a year in new giving, what Nan Ransohoff calls "[the third wave of American philanthropy](https://nanransohoff.substack.com/p/the-third-wave-of-american-philanthropy)." If she's right, thousands of people are about to become very wealthy, starting with Anthropic's IPO and OpenAI's after it, and many want to fund what AI can't make: meaning, beauty, connection.

Public media should be part of the answer. But are we even at the table? Most of these donors have never thought about their local station, let alone seen it as an antidote to the loneliness and polarization of commercial and generated media. Perhaps this is nothing more than a visibility and positioning problem. Or maybe delivering on the 4C's requires deeper product and service transformation. In the meantime, commercial radio already markets itself as "[guaranteed human](https://radioinsight.com/headlines/322054/iheart-launches-anti-ai-guaranteed-human-campaign/?ref=shannonconnolly.org)." Public media has been human all along and, for some reason, isn't saying so.

With some imagination, "the cultural infrastructure that gives life meaning" could describe the promise of public media. The first wave of American philanthropy built the public library; the third could build what comes after the broadcast tower. But it will take more than a brand campaign and a repositioning. These donors grew up in tech. They fund a thesis, a team, speed, and metrics, not a mission or a need. So imagine this: if your budget grew tenfold tomorrow, and you stopped waiting for NPR to fund what you need, what would you build yourself? A station that can answer in a sentence has made itself legible, and a legible station is one someone can fund.

Both playbooks, constraints and abundance, depend on membership, the revenue that buys independence, which is foundational for trust. Gen Z is choosing wired headphones, vinyl, flip phones, and "I voted" stickers: analog symbols of an identity that is independent and intentional. They should want the tote bag, too. Not as a badge of affluence, but as a sign that you listen, you show up, you belong to a place. That you're part of a "we," not just a "me."

So how does every station make a tote bag that sells out? Not just during the pledge drive, but all year long? And how can station heads not just get a seat at the table, but use this moment to become the main course: the default signal, the one we tune into and trust, together?